Integrated helmet lamp vs detachable helmet flashlight

Which helmet lighting system is more interesting for a fire service?
6 June, 2022

In recent years, we have seen how some firefighter helmet manufacturers have launched their own models of integrated flashlights. A priori, the concept behind this product makes sense: incorporate a flashlight to the helmet to improve ergonomics and, incidentally, generate business with the addition of a new accessory to their catalogue. However, is ergonomics the main attribute when we need lighting equipment?

After many conversations with firefighters from different countries, all agree that the main characteristics of a helmet flashlight should be: light output, burning time, weight and safety (ATEX certification).

The advantages of the integrated versions include its ergonomics/harmony with the helmet shell and the joint purchase from a single supplier (helmet and flashlight). However, there are many limitations or disadvantages:

 

    • Lack of light output (all users agree that it is only a reading light).
    • Not being able to change the direction of the light beam, which is an inconvenience when you are face to face with another person.
    • There are only alkaline battery versions, not rechargeable (it is a major expense per year and the need to replace them on a regular basis for which a tool is required).
    • Can only be used with one type of helmet (not interchangeable with a rescue helmet or other type).
    • There is no certified model for ATEX zone 0/20 potentially explosive atmospheres (most manufacturers only offer zone 1 gases and no dust versions).
    • Limited range of models (most have only one version).
    • In addition, some users are not even satisfied with their ergonomics, as they are located on the front and their weight exerts pressure forward.

As an alternative, there’s the traditional detachable flashlight, which has a large number of advantages:

 

    • Increased power and light output (for example, the L-30 with 350 lm).
    • Wide range of manufacturers and models on the market.
    • Versions with rechargeable battery or non-reusable batteries.
    • The possibility to change the direction of the light according to needs.
    • Greater burning time.
    • Wide array of features to choose from (step light, red beacon, light sensor among others).
    • Interchangeable: can be adapted to different types of helmets (structural, rescue and others).
    • Safer. There are certified models for ATEX zone 0/20 potentially explosive atmospheres.